Contributor
•
53 Messages
XG1v4 requires reboot everyday...
After a recent move, we upgraded from our old X1 box to the new 4K "XG1v4-A" box to work with our Samsung 4K UHD television.
We immediately realized that our box was requiring a reboot every day. So, we've been unplugging the box and plugging it back in. I've contact Xfinity about this issue several times. No one over the phone has been able to help.
Xfinity tech support simply had me swap out my box for a new one (which they have to send via FedEx -- requiring me to drop off the old box to the Xfinity store). This is the third box and I still have the same issue.
So, Xfinity sent out a tech yesterday. We were also having some internet connectivity problems (intermittent loss of internet on all of our devices). He discovered that the splice was installed by the Xfinity installation guy incorrectly (or so he said).
However, the tech was puzzled. He said that everything should be working. He then attempted to say that our "problem" was our television.
I explained that we have swapped to another TV that worked perfectly fine (trading my sister-in-law's for a few days). Our television worked perfectly fine at her house with Xfinity and her TV worked fine at our house using the same box and same HDMI cable.
I explained to the tech that this didn't happen with the old X1 box. It doesn't happen with anything else connected to the TV (e.g., Xbox One, Blu-ray, etc.). I've even swapped HDMI cords, switched HDMI inputs, etc. Each and every time, the problem is only with the new XG1v4 box.
The tech then said that he thinks that the cable issue that he "fixed" might solve the issue. He left roughly 25 minutes after arriving and said that he would have someone follow-up with me in a couple of days.
Today, I turned everything on again....and have the same problem.
My TV is a Samsung 4K UHD television.
My power save mode is OFF.
My HDMI cable is 2.0 compatible (and I've tried FIVE of them -- all with the same issue).
My TV's firmware is up-to-date.
Apparently, this is a known issue. There are quite a few threads on the Xfinity forums with many posters addressing this issue. For instance:
https://forums.xfinity.com/t5/TV-Archive/XG1v4-requires-reboot/td-p/3025141
Doe anyone have a resolution?
huskur
Frequent Visitor
•
9 Messages
6 years ago
0
0
Speters147
New Poster
•
4 Messages
6 years ago
I see this with my box as well. I just traded in my old non X1 box that performed well for the last 5 years. My first X1 box was DOA as was the second. The third box worked. Every morning I have to reboot the box to get a picture. It isn’t the cable and it isn’t the TV. I figured out it is after they do the daily updates. Every time Comcast remotely accesses the box for their daily whatever, it bricks the box. I changed the time from 4 am to 2 pm and when I got home from work today, it was bricked. It follows the daily update time. It is likely a software issue that is not compatible with the hardware. This should be something they should fix ASAP or there will be a lawsuit against them. It is unreal. I’m going to turn off as many features as I can to see if there is some feature incompatibility during the daily updates that is causing the issue. I doubt it though. Probably need a different model box, like maybe my old one, that will fix this. Techs and calls to service won’t get you anywhere. It is a software/hardware compatibility issue thatgot past their quality control testing, if they do any.
0
huskur
Frequent Visitor
•
9 Messages
6 years ago
0
0
ahu1
Frequent Visitor
•
19 Messages
6 years ago
There are only two HDMI ports on the XG1v4. One is labeled "Input". The other one is labeled "HDMI TV". Obviously, the TV is connected to the latter.
0
0
ahu1
Frequent Visitor
•
19 Messages
6 years ago
Huskur, can you please explain in detail what HDMI port did you swap and how. You apparently have a Vizio TV. Many of the complaints were reported by users who have Samsunk 4K TVs. The remedy may not be the same with those. Thanks.
0
0
huskur
Frequent Visitor
•
9 Messages
6 years ago
0
0
ahu1
Frequent Visitor
•
19 Messages
6 years ago
I see. The cable is already plugged to HDMI 1. HDMI 4 only is ARC on my TV. The cable will be harder to swap because it is builder-installed behind the drywall. But I will do some testing outside. Thanks again.
0
0
Speters147
New Poster
•
4 Messages
6 years ago
If it is an HDMI issue, then you should be able to unplug and plug back in the cable to bring back the picture. That would indicate an HDCP handshake issue. I doubt that is it, but I’ll try it tomorrow when my box bricks again after the daily update. I also turned off just about every feature on the box that is programmable so will see if that does anything. If not, I’m taking the box back and getting the non-X1 box. I have a Vizio TV and my box is X1 but not the 4K box. I am using the same HDMI cable I was using with my old box that had no issues.
0
0
ahu1
Frequent Visitor
•
19 Messages
6 years ago
I will be interested in what you find. I already tried disconnecting the HDMI cable in an attempt to bring the picture back from black screen but it did not help. I have XG1v4 4K DVR, so that could make a difference indeed.
0
0
huskur
Frequent Visitor
•
9 Messages
6 years ago
0
0
huskur
Frequent Visitor
•
9 Messages
6 years ago
0
0
Speters147
New Poster
•
4 Messages
6 years ago
Ok, I have done a couple experiments in the last two days with interesting results. I’m honing in on it and will get to a solution but I’m not there yet.
I have the non 4K box. I have HDMI going through a receiver to my TV using ARC HDMI port. Here is what I did.
1) Disabled every available programmable feature.
Result- Black screen and no picture after daily update
Action 1 - unplugged and plugged back in the HDMI cable.
Result- No change
Action 2- unplugged and plugged back in the RF cable on the back of the box
Result-Picture came back
Conclusion-Box does not have to be rebooted
2) Next day - unplugged HDMI cable before I went to work. Daily update occurred.
Action 1- Plugged in HDMI cable. Then turned on TV.
Result: No picture.
Action 2- Unplugged HDMI cable and plugged back in.
Result: Picture came on after a slight delay
Conclusion: Hmmm. May be an HDMI handshaking issue. Also picture came back after delay, so I’m wondering in day 1 if I didn’t wait long enough
Planned experiments:
Bypass received and go straight to TV with Comcast provided HDMI cable.
After daily update, if no picture, change HDMI port on TV and then switch back. Determine if pic comes back. If so this may be an acceptable compromise. If not, I’ll unplug HDMI and plug back in. If that fixes it, I may try using a non ARC Port. Not sure where to go if that doesn’t work. I’ll get my old box back!
Maybe someone else can try some of these to see if they work on the 4K box. Wonder why they didn’t give me a 4K box!
0
0
Z3papa
Frequent Visitor
•
11 Messages
6 years ago
Their supplied HDMI cable caused error problems for me day 1. My HDMI cable did not for 22 months. Yesterday, the box would not start up. Box reboots and system restores allowed the secondary box which runs off the primary box data to operate, but not the primary. Code XR-00075 or something. I could even pull up the guide because my TV is paired to the primary box but could not open any channels. 90 minutes on the phone where they repeated the same trouble shooting efforts I already did resulted in a service call. Service guy said the system said it wasn't the box but the drop line had experienced issues. He replaced the line which increased internet speeds but problem persisted. When he realized the box would never activate but that upstairs secondary unit was working, he realized the primary box was not putting out video. He's been doing this for 15 year and said the XG1v4 has presented more problems than any other unit. Moral of the story is if your having to continually reboot, something is probably wrong.
0
Rustyben
Expert
•
24.6K Messages
6 years ago
besides your DVR do you have at least one XG2 companion set top box? it can supply tuners and access to the internet for other devices (like wireless xi5/xi6 or the coax connected xi3/xid). that would free up the tuners in your DVR.
0
0
Audiomixer
Contributor
•
45 Messages
6 years ago
It has to be some sort of software issue with HDMI handshakes.
I have the X1 box and have had issues for 2 months.
But this past week, things seemed to have resolved themselves.
It was a software issue that they got around to addressing; at leaset for the X1 boxes.
0