On demand X1 upgrade question

@MNtundraRET​ Xfinity Internet is no longer a requirement for X1.

I have seen or heard nothing about that change. It would be helpful if change goes through.

@jweaver0312​ We are being expected to upgrade from Legacy Service to X1 Service to keep our OnDemand.  I read your response above and want to clarify:  So upgrading to X1 Service for my cable will work okay with my AT&T Internet?  Everyone I have asked this question to at Xfinity gives me a different answer.  Most say they don't know and that I should just order the new X1 boxes and see if they work.  If not, bring them back.  I don't want to change my internet carrier to maintain my OnDemand Service.  Please advise.

@user_55b1b2​ It should not need to work with AT&T Internet.  Since cable never required internet, this forced change should not require ANY internet connection if they are being truthful (although, of course, they could use the either the internet or a private network through the cable wire in a manner "invisible" to the user, as long as they don't charge extra for it.)

@jweaver0312 

The information they gave you was wrong. Jessie clarified the issue on 5/4/23. We now need a newer version on the Legacy Cable box for those of us using Internet from another company. I am still waiting to hear which one(s).