Peacock keeps opening the same episode of a series, instead of remembering which episode I was on before

Every show I watch ends up picking an episode to 'get stuck' on, and everytime I go back into Peacock and start that show it goes to a timestamp within that episode instead of the episode that I'm on.

For example, with Modern Family it always goes to the holiday episode scene where the mother fakes cutting her fingers off
Or with Americas Got Talent its always the 1st set of auditions about 1/3rd of the way through the episode.

Is there any way to fix this?