Windows 10, LAN on MB (10/100/1000). MoCA filter and splitter where cable enters house - one leg to video distribution box, second leg directly to my modem. Had 200 MB plan and was getting around 180 MB. Upgraded plan to 1200 MB and modem (Arris SB8200, DOCSIS 3.1), Cat 6 directly from desktop directly to modem port just to test - would "spike" speed to around 700 MB then immediately throttle down to 320 MB - 380 MB. Reset and reprovisioned modem twice. No change. Had Comcast Tech out who checked speed at pole (1200 MB), speed at tap for house (1200 MB), speed at modem (1200 MB) with "excellent power levels" per Xfinity Tech. Add SB8200 in the mix and speed drops to 320-380 MB. Tech said "Speeds based on our equipment. SB8200 might not hold full boot file. Try our Xfi modem." Did that - same speeds. Would spike to around 600 MB then drop back to 320-380 MB. Hmmm, ok. Try another gig speed modem. Got a Netgear CM1200 yesterday. Set up with Cat 6 direct from desktop to modem. Testing wee hours of the AM and get a little better but not much - certainly not 1 GB.
Using speedtest.net app in W10 rather than browser test - Browser test is consistently 50-100 MB slower. Modem reports:
Startup Procedure
Procedure
Status
Comment
Acquire Downstream Channel
627000000 Hz
Locked
Connectivity State
OK
Operational
Boot State
OK
Operational
Security
Enabled
BPI+
IP Provisioning Mode
Honor MDD
honorMdd(4)
Downstream Bonded Channels
Channel
Lock Status
Modulation
Channel ID
Frequency
Power
SNR
Correctables
Uncorrectables
1
Locked
QAM256
32
627000000 Hz
7.8 dBmV
41.2 dB
0
0
2
Locked
QAM256
1
435000000 Hz
6.3 dBmV
40.6 dB
0
0
3
Locked
QAM256
2
441000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
4
Locked
QAM256
3
447000000 Hz
6.3 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
5
Locked
QAM256
4
453000000 Hz
5.9 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
6
Locked
QAM256
5
459000000 Hz
5.8 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
7
Locked
QAM256
6
465000000 Hz
5.4 dBmV
40.4 dB
0
0
8
Locked
QAM256
7
471000000 Hz
5.5 dBmV
40.4 dB
0
0
9
Locked
QAM256
8
477000000 Hz
5.5 dBmV
40.4 dB
0
0
10
Locked
QAM256
9
483000000 Hz
5.8 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
11
Locked
QAM256
10
489000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
12
Locked
QAM256
11
495000000 Hz
6.4 dBmV
40.4 dB
0
0
13
Locked
QAM256
12
507000000 Hz
6.7 dBmV
40.5 dB
0
0
14
Locked
QAM256
13
513000000 Hz
6.8 dBmV
40.6 dB
0
0
15
Locked
QAM256
14
519000000 Hz
6.3 dBmV
40.6 dB
0
0
16
Locked
QAM256
15
525000000 Hz
6.6 dBmV
40.8 dB
0
0
17
Locked
QAM256
16
531000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
40.8 dB
0
0
18
Locked
QAM256
18
543000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
40.7 dB
0
0
19
Locked
QAM256
19
549000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
40.7 dB
0
0
20
Locked
QAM256
20
555000000 Hz
6.7 dBmV
40.9 dB
0
0
21
Locked
QAM256
21
561000000 Hz
7.1 dBmV
40.9 dB
0
0
22
Locked
QAM256
22
567000000 Hz
7.4 dBmV
41.1 dB
0
0
23
Locked
QAM256
23
573000000 Hz
7.4 dBmV
40.9 dB
0
0
24
Locked
QAM256
24
579000000 Hz
7 dBmV
40.9 dB
0
0
25
Locked
QAM256
25
585000000 Hz
6.8 dBmV
40.8 dB
0
0
26
Locked
QAM256
26
591000000 Hz
6.5 dBmV
41 dB
0
0
27
Locked
QAM256
27
597000000 Hz
6.1 dBmV
41.1 dB
0
0
28
Locked
QAM256
28
603000000 Hz
6.9 dBmV
41.2 dB
0
0
29
Locked
QAM256
29
609000000 Hz
5.8 dBmV
41 dB
0
0
30
Locked
QAM256
30
615000000 Hz
7 dBmV
41 dB
0
0
31
Locked
QAM256
31
621000000 Hz
6.7 dBmV
41 dB
0
0
32
Not Locked
Unknown
0
0 Hz
0.0 dBmV
0.0 dB
0
0
Upstream Bonded Channels
Channel
Lock Status
US Channel Type
Channel ID
Symbol Rate
Frequency
Power
1
Locked
ATDMA
1
5120 Ksym/sec
35600000 Hz
43.5 dBmV
2
Locked
ATDMA
2
5120 Ksym/sec
29200000 Hz
44 dBmV
3
Locked
ATDMA
3
5120 Ksym/sec
22800000 Hz
44 dBmV
4
Locked
ATDMA
4
5120 Ksym/sec
16400000 Hz
44 dBmV
5
Not Locked
Unknown
0
0 Ksym/sec
0 Hz
0.0 dBmV
6
Not Locked
Unknown
0
0 Ksym/sec
0 Hz
0.0 dBmV
7
Not Locked
Unknown
0
0 Ksym/sec
0 Hz
0.0 dBmV
8
Not Locked
Unknown
0
0 Ksym/sec
0 Hz
0.0 dBmV
Downstream OFDM Channels
Channel
Lock Status
Modulation / Profile ID
Channel ID
Frequency
Power
SNR / MER
Active Subcarrier Number Range
Unerrored Codewords
Correctable Codewords
Uncorrectable Codewords
1
Locked
0 ,1 ,2 ,3
33
678000000 Hz
7.7 dBmV
40.6 dB
1108 ~ 2987
107783651
105295721
0
2
Not Locked
0
0
0 Hz
0 dBmV
0.0 dB
0 ~ 4095
0
0
0
Upstream OFDMA Channels
Channel
Lock Status
Modulation / Profile ID
Channel ID
Frequency
Power
1
Not Locked
0
0
0 Hz
0 dBmV
2
Not Locked
0
0
0 Hz
0 dBmV
Extended Upstream Transmit Power
Enable Extended Upstream Transmit Power
Current System Time:Sun Mar 28 06:41:00 2021
System Up Time:13:47:03
I'm at a loss to explain why I'm not getting the plan's reported speed. I think I've isolated just about everything on the system except changing out LAN card in desktop but I'm thinking that's not it since I was briefly seeing 700-800MB before it dropped back down to 320-380MB. Coax cable from tap on line to modem - check (good - no interference, no power drop, per Xfinity Tech). Cat 6 - check (good, tried two different ones). Modem - Check (three different modems, three different manufacturers). Power levels in spec - check (Xfinity Tech confirmed).
I'm at a loss to figure this out. Hopefully someone will have an idea.
@brintonh how are you checking the speeds? with a computer? The reason i ask is, i would check your network card drivers, or network card its self, i just got a so called plug and play adapter, 2.5 gig, so it played alright, but at speeds 1/3 of what i should have got, after some research i ended up on my new adapters webpage, so on that page it said flat out you would not get the advertised speeds if you used Microsoft drivers, so i installed the correct driver, this happened, i use a xb7, so maybe install the drivers from the network adapters webpage, just a thought
@steagallcraig @jlavaseur For some reason neither of your comments are showing up. I can see them in my emails but not on this forum.
@brintonh "how are you checking the speeds? with a computer? The reason i ask is, i would check your network card drivers, or network card its self, i just got a so called plug and play adapter, 2.5 gig, so it played alright, but at speeds 1/3 of what i should have got, after some research i ended up on my new adapters webpage, so on that page it said flat out you would not get the advertised speeds if you used Microsoft drivers, so i installed the correct driver, this happened, i use a xb7, so maybe install the drivers from the network adapters webpage",
Response: I have Realteck LAN built in to the Asrock motherboard. Tried both the W10 driver but as part of my sniffing out all this problem, I installed the Realteck driver too. Didn't make much of a difference.
@jlavaseur I check the speeds with the W10 speedtest.net app, not the browser-based speedtests. I consistently get 100 Mbps faster with the app. A bit messy but here's the app vs the Xfinity Site (Chrome Browser).
Ok, just a thought here, ok so your getting the speed at the pole etc, multiple modems, so my rational leeds me to the network adapter, the fact you upgraded from a slower speed and didn't seem to have issues, personally i would try to uninstall that network adapter and reboot, i have had corrupted drivers that didn't function properly, but still worked, just a thought
From what I am seeing, the specs of your equipment on our website here: https://comca.st/3ukJD3P does only recommend the modem that you have now for speeds of up to 800 Mbps, with our new Gigabit speed being provisioned for up to 1.2 Gbps, the modem you have now can only deliver and be provisioned for up to 1 Gbps so what happens is a conflict of abilities of the modem and what we are trying to push through. We're trying to push through the right Gigabit bootfile, but that bootfile is for 1.2 Gbps which your equipment is not designed for. This is why once it is connected there is a mismatch happening and the speed is actually slowed down from its maximum ability. If you go to the website and review the devices that are recommended for the new faster Gigabit speed, you'll see there are only 5 that are listed as recommended and compatible with our infrastructure, unfortunately your current device is not listed with the new higher gigabit speed.
@steagallcraig@jlavaseur Look at the list of approved gigabit speed modems. Check out the comments if you enter Motorola 8611 in the search function for these forums. No better than the issues we're having!
@steagallcraig@jlavaseurWell, Step 1 complete. Motorola MB8611 installed and provisioned. Bottom two tests, one from last night and then again this AM, are with the Netgear CM1200.
The Netgear seems to be a little faster but not by much. Seems when I do sequential testing (i.e., one test right after the other) it gets a little faster each time. Still not getting close to 1 GB speed.
Step 2: My new NIC card with 2.5G base should come tomorrow via Amazon; however, with it being Easter, might not happen so probably Monday. The Arris SB8200 isn't back yet either. So I'll leave the Motorola for now while awaiting the new NIC.
Step 3: If the new NIC works better with the Motorola, I'll see if I get the same with the SB8200. If so then the Netgear and Motorola are back to Amazon. Here's the power levels with the Motorola:
@ComcastJamesH@ComcastAlyssa You guys have any further comments on what I'm seeing with the various modems? The post immediately above is with the new Motorola MB8611. That's now 3 different modems on your approved list for my speed tier - Arris SB8200, Motorola MB8611 and Netgear CM1200 - and also tried your Xfinity Xfi Gateway as well.
wow. that is a 1gb plan? I am not even going down the new modem path. I will just drop my plan down to 800. Its been a year and I haven't got close to 1gb speed.
scraig2
Contributor
•
60 Messages
4 years ago
here is what was deleted or just happens to have never posted.
0
0
Jlavaseur
Problem Solver
•
948 Messages
4 years ago
@brintonh how are you checking the speeds? with a computer? The reason i ask is, i would check your network card drivers, or network card its self, i just got a so called plug and play adapter, 2.5 gig, so it played alright, but at speeds 1/3 of what i should have got, after some research i ended up on my new adapters webpage, so on that page it said flat out you would not get the advertised speeds if you used Microsoft drivers, so i installed the correct driver, this happened, i use a xb7, so maybe install the drivers from the network adapters webpage, just a thought
(edited)
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@steagallcraig @jlavaseur For some reason neither of your comments are showing up. I can see them in my emails but not on this forum.
@brintonh "how are you checking the speeds? with a computer? The reason i ask is, i would check your network card drivers, or network card its self, i just got a so called plug and play adapter, 2.5 gig, so it played alright, but at speeds 1/3 of what i should have got, after some research i ended up on my new adapters webpage, so on that page it said flat out you would not get the advertised speeds if you used Microsoft drivers, so i installed the correct driver, this happened, i use a xb7, so maybe install the drivers from the network adapters webpage",
Response: I have Realteck LAN built in to the Asrock motherboard. Tried both the W10 driver but as part of my sniffing out all this problem, I installed the Realteck driver too. Didn't make much of a difference.
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@jlavaseur I check the speeds with the W10 speedtest.net app, not the browser-based speedtests. I consistently get 100 Mbps faster with the app. A bit messy but here's the app vs the Xfinity Site (Chrome Browser).
0
0
Jlavaseur
Problem Solver
•
948 Messages
4 years ago
Ok, just a thought here, ok so your getting the speed at the pole etc, multiple modems, so my rational leeds me to the network adapter, the fact you upgraded from a slower speed and didn't seem to have issues, personally i would try to uninstall that network adapter and reboot, i have had corrupted drivers that didn't function properly, but still worked, just a thought
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
Good thought. Uninstall through "Device Manager"?
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
And it'll come back when I reboot?
0
0
Jlavaseur
Problem Solver
•
948 Messages
4 years ago
Yes it will, yes thru device manager
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@jlavaseur Good idea. Done. Pulled in same Realteck driver. No significant difference in speeds:
(edited)
0
0
scraig2
Contributor
•
60 Messages
4 years ago
well here is the latest from my chat.....
From what I am seeing, the specs of your equipment on our website here: https://comca.st/3ukJD3P does only recommend the modem that you have now for speeds of up to 800 Mbps, with our new Gigabit speed being provisioned for up to 1.2 Gbps, the modem you have now can only deliver and be provisioned for up to 1 Gbps so what happens is a conflict of abilities of the modem and what we are trying to push through. We're trying to push through the right Gigabit bootfile, but that bootfile is for 1.2 Gbps which your equipment is not designed for. This is why once it is connected there is a mismatch happening and the speed is actually slowed down from its maximum ability. If you go to the website and review the devices that are recommended for the new faster Gigabit speed, you'll see there are only 5 that are listed as recommended and compatible with our infrastructure, unfortunately your current device is not listed with the new higher gigabit speed.
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@steagallcraig @jlavaseur Look at the list of approved gigabit speed modems. Check out the comments if you enter Motorola 8611 in the search function for these forums. No better than the issues we're having!
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@steagallcraig @jlavaseur Well, Step 1 complete. Motorola MB8611 installed and provisioned. Bottom two tests, one from last night and then again this AM, are with the Netgear CM1200.
The Netgear seems to be a little faster but not by much. Seems when I do sequential testing (i.e., one test right after the other) it gets a little faster each time. Still not getting close to 1 GB speed.
Step 2: My new NIC card with 2.5G base should come tomorrow via Amazon; however, with it being Easter, might not happen so probably Monday. The Arris SB8200 isn't back yet either. So I'll leave the Motorola for now while awaiting the new NIC.
Step 3: If the new NIC works better with the Motorola, I'll see if I get the same with the SB8200. If so then the Netgear and Motorola are back to Amazon. Here's the power levels with the Motorola:
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@ComcastJamesH @ComcastAlyssa You guys have any further comments on what I'm seeing with the various modems? The post immediately above is with the new Motorola MB8611. That's now 3 different modems on your approved list for my speed tier - Arris SB8200, Motorola MB8611 and Netgear CM1200 - and also tried your Xfinity Xfi Gateway as well.
0
0
brintonh
Contributor
•
33 Messages
4 years ago
@ComcastJamesH @ComcastAlyssa
0
0
scraig2
Contributor
•
60 Messages
4 years ago
wow. that is a 1gb plan? I am not even going down the new modem path. I will just drop my plan down to 800. Its been a year and I haven't got close to 1gb speed.
0
0