6 Messages
CM2050V instability after firmware upgrade
As others have mentioned, it appears that recently Xfinity pushed v9 of firmware to the Netgear CM2050V modems. Netgear's site still lists V2.01.03 as the supported version but I suppose that may just be a lag in updating the site. The modem is now running v9.01.01. Since the upgrade I have multiple issues of latency and disconnects per day.
I have contacted Xfinity technical support multiple times and they are [Edited: "Inflammatory"]. They insisted on sending a technician to check the line. He came, verified on his stats that in the last 24 hours the cable modem (only) had 1200+ disconnects. The rest of cable (TV ,etc. had 0 issues disconnects). He verified there was no physical issue with the signal.
Technical support doesn't even admit that firmware upgrades are handled by Xfinity. Netgear says issues must be addressed by Xfinity. Xfinity says the issue must be addressed by Netgear.
The simple solution that I suspect would solve the issue is to downgrade back to the stable version but I cannot do this and no one is even willing to admit that is possible.
Below is a modem diagnostic of one of the instances of connectivity issue.
Cable Diagnostic
Status: Poor
Action:
[Partial Service]
If the Partial Service mode does not go away within a few hours (Click the Refresh button after each step):
1) Make sure the coaxial cable is tightly connected.
2) Remove any unnecessary splitters.
3) Replace any required ones.
4) Contact your service provider for troubleshooting help.
CM Status: Good
Downstream Status: Poor
Partial Service: Poor
Cable modem is in partial service mode. Your service provider might be under maintenance. Most of the time it won't affect your traffic and will automatically clear when work is complete.
Downstream Power Level: Good
Downstream SNR Level: Good
Upstream Status: Good
Upstream Power Level: Good
Current Time: Tue Nov 21 15:34:25 2023
Startup Procedure
Acquire Downstream Channel: 543000000 Hz Locked
Connectivity State: OK Operational
Boot State: OK Operational
Security: Enabled BPI+
IP Provisioning Mode: Honor MDD IPv6 only
Downstream Bonded Channels (Partial Service)
Channel LockedStatus Modulation ChannelID Frequency Power SNR Correctables Uncorrectables
1 Locked QAM256 20 543000000 Hz -2 40.6 3602857 826
2 Locked QAM256 1 417000000 Hz -1.7 40.6 153405 1845
3 Locked QAM256 2 423000000 Hz -1.8 40.6 196357 1684
4 Locked QAM256 3 429000000 Hz -1.8 40.5 176913 1544
5 Locked QAM256 4 435000000 Hz -1.9 40.5 157622 1419
6 Locked QAM256 5 441000000 Hz -2.2 40.5 150110 1368
7 Locked QAM256 6 447000000 Hz -2.3 40.4 147506 1031
8 Locked QAM256 7 453000000 Hz -2.6 40.3 156174 660
9 Locked QAM256 8 459000000 Hz -2.8 40.3 162987 709
10 Locked QAM256 9 465000000 Hz -2.8 40.2 161298 578
11 Locked QAM256 10 471000000 Hz -2.8 40.2 178635 447
12 Locked QAM256 11 477000000 Hz -2.8 40.2 217059 390
13 Locked QAM256 12 483000000 Hz -2.8 40.2 298011 371
14 Locked QAM256 13 489000000 Hz -2.7 40.1 499347 366
15 Locked QAM256 14 495000000 Hz -2.6 40.1 2189136 392
16 Locked QAM256 15 507000000 Hz -2.4 40.3 837498 443
17 Locked QAM256 16 513000000 Hz -2.3 40.3 851484 465
18 Locked QAM256 17 519000000 Hz -2.1 40.4 1148721 530
19 Locked QAM256 18 525000000 Hz -1.9 40.5 1854560 905
20 Locked QAM256 19 531000000 Hz -1.8 40.5 7507820 950
21 Locked QAM256 21 549000000 Hz -2 40.5 3078475 895
22 Locked QAM256 22 555000000 Hz -2.3 40.5 3274929 954
23 Locked QAM256 23 561000000 Hz -2.4 40.4 3450505 1041
24 Locked QAM256 24 567000000 Hz -2.5 40.4 4009972 1064
25 Locked QAM256 25 573000000 Hz -2.4 40.4 4448191 1087
26 Locked QAM256 26 579000000 Hz -2.3 40.4 5144046 1214
27 Locked QAM256 27 585000000 Hz -2 40.5 5854640 1379
28 Locked QAM256 28 591000000 Hz -1.7 40.6 6526046 1305
29 Locked QAM256 29 597000000 Hz -1.2 40.6 7136586 1446
30 Locked QAM256 30 603000000 Hz -0.8 40.7 7728517 1420
31 Locked QAM256 31 609000000 Hz -0.6 40.8 8556730 1378
32 Locked QAM256 32 615000000 Hz -0.5 40.8 9581736 1514
Upstream Bonded Channels
Channel LockedStatus ChannelType ChannelID SymbolRate Frequency Power
1 Locked ATDMA 4 5120 Ksym/sec 35600000 Hz 41.8 dBmV
2 Locked ATDMA 2 5120 Ksym/sec 22800000 Hz 41.3 dBmV
3 Locked ATDMA 3 5120 Ksym/sec 29200000 Hz 41.0 dBmV
4 Locked ATDMA 1 5120 Ksym/sec 16400000 Hz 41.0 dBmV
5 Locked ATDMA 5 2560 Ksym/sec 40400000 Hz 42.8 dBmV
6 Locked ATDMA 6 2560 Ksym/sec 10400000 Hz 42.8 dBmV
7 Not Locked Unknown 0 0 0 0.0
8 Not Locked Unknown 0 0 0 0.0
Downstream OFDM Channels
Channel LockedStatus ProfileID ChannelID Frequency Power SNR/MER ActiveSubcarrier Unerror Correctable Uncorrectable
1 Locked 0 ,1 ,2 ,3 193 722000000 Hz -0.52 dBmV 40.0 dB 1108 ~ 2987 446897319 293372641 83348428
2 Not Locked 0 0 0 Hz 0 dBmV 0 dB 0 ~ 4095 0 0 0
Upstream OFDMA Channels
Channel LockedStatus ProfileID ChannelID Frequency Power
1 Not Locked 0 0 0 Hz 0 dBmV
2 Not Locked 0 0 0 Hz 0 dBmV
Event Log
Official Solution
XfinityBillie
Official Employee
•
2.8K Messages
1 year ago
Thank you for taking the time to work with us here on our Xfinity Forums. As discussed, firmware updates and patches are provided by the manufacturer. Once the manufacturer makes one available it would be pushed to your modem.
2
0
XfinityPaula
Official Employee
•
1.2K Messages
1 year ago
Hello @user_75kysp Thank you for sharing the trouble you have been having with the connections on the modem since the most recent firmware update. I'm sorry for the trouble with the service and with having the issue addressed. I would love to help and try to figure this out for us and as needed have it brought to the attention of our repair teams. Our normal process seems to have been followed already with a repair appointment and all signal levels checked. If the service to the modem is good, that next thing to work on would be the modem. Considering this is an owned device it goes beyond our demarcation, and we have to refer you back to the manufacturer. I don't want you to have to go back and forth between us and Netgear so let's open a request and see what details we can gather and see if others are having an issue as well. It's my understanding that the firmware is developed by the manufacturer and pushed to devices automatically when they are reset.
Please send us a direct message with your name and service address. From there we will run through a few steps and open a request to have this investigated.
To send a direct message, please click on the chat icon in the top-right corner of the screen, and select "Xfinity Support" to initiate a live chat.
Click "Sign In" if necessary
Click the "direct messaging" icon or https://comca.st/3J0ir1l
Click the "New message" (pencil and paper) icon
Type "Xfinity Support" in the "To:" line and select "Xfinity Support" from the drop-down list which appears. The "Xfinity Support" graphic replaces the "To:" line
Type your message in the text area near the bottom of the window
Press Enter to send it
2
0
ralfo72
Contributor
•
36 Messages
1 year ago
This same issue is widespread and the common theme is there is nothing wrong with connectors, wiring and modems and you are [Edited: "Inflammatory"]. I have been having this same issue post F/W upgrade that coincided with mid split upgrades. My modem like clockwork with loose sync every 1-2 weeks and won’t recover unless I reboot it by power disconnect. Xfinity pushes out the firmware and always has in customer modems. Everyone’s device was solid until you did this [Edited: "Inflammatory"]. This needs to be escalated as this same story is in multiple forums and all your doing is [Edited: "Inflammatory"].
[Edited: "Inflammatory"] have your engineers look into this.
(edited)
8
user_8f3a46
5 Messages
1 year ago
And I have had nothing but problems with the service since September and then a week ago finally support admits 1 modem is bad and I get the new one and when until recently I had ALWAYS had download speeds of 800 mbs+ now as can barely get anything close to 300 mbs and have even has as low as 93 PER XFINITY SPEED TEST!!!!! I am fed up as support has been trash for 3 months now from programming to boxes you couldn't fix to now modems!!!! It just keeps getting worse!!!!
5
0
user_75kysp
6 Messages
1 year ago
@XfinityThomasA ... you keep suggesting "opening up a chat with support so they can look at the problem". As I have indicated, I did this... multiple times. Each time the end result (after an hour of having to explain the situation, go through the mandatory troubleshooting playbook the result is always the same. The support person indicates "it is a 3rd party modem, Xfinity doesn't handle issues with firmware with those". In my case I have now reverted back to a rental modem so my nice, expensive owned modem is sitting on a shelf anyway. There is no reason for me to swap it back in until someone from Xfinity can confirm they have a patched firmware version they can push or they can push a downgrade to the stable version (v2). Notice I say Xfinity because only Xfinity can push the firmware to these modems as per the manufacturer. There is no end user capability for updating the firmware (annoying but true). I'm going to assume that if if you response "your experience is important to us, contact support" that you are simply a chatbot and aren't a human actually trying to help by reading and understanding what your customers are saying.
0
user_cjlhq1
1 Message
1 year ago
I have the same modem and the same issue - started last week for me. Tech came out a replaced a line today and a request is in to increase power levels...however if this is a firmware issue, not sure what help that will be.
Anyone have any luck on reverting to a stable firmware version?
1
0
Joep42
Contributor
•
22 Messages
1 year ago
Went to use my scanner yesterday (Canon MX920 Printer/Scanner) always connected to my Netgear CM2050V modem via Wi-Fi and got message No Scanner Attached. I first thought it might be the recent Apple OS Sonoma upgrade so I went to my other system (Windows 10) and it too could not connect the scanner to the network.
Did all the usual PD including factory resetting both the modem and Canon MX920. No luck. Switching the MX920 to a USB connection solved the scanner issues on both systems.
Found that Comcast site says latest firmware is V2.01.03 but router says V9.0101 is installed. I have no other issues with the modem (speed, stability, etc.). While the Netgear modem is exclusive to Comcast, Comcast says contact Netgear support. Netgear says contact Comcast. Just great.
0
0
user_gaaxa0
2 Messages
11 months ago
I have the CM2050V with 1200 speed plan, use to get 600/800 speeds, now it drops frequently, won't sink up for hours and when it does best speeds I receive straight from the cable modem wired are 80 mbps.
It's been like this for a few weeks now.
2
0
user_iznj8g
2 Messages
11 months ago
I am having exactly the same issue with v9.01.01. Many downstream disconnects a day. Comcast says it's netgears problem. Netgear says it's Comcast problem. Terrible customer support on both ends. I am stuck and No one will help ot take responsibility.
3
0
somp
Contributor
•
19 Messages
11 months ago
Comcast just revert the firmware back to v2.01.03 this morning .It is too early to say if it fix this problem.
2
0
somp
Contributor
•
19 Messages
11 months ago
Update, lost Ofdma, upload speed drop from 119 to 90.
0
0
somp
Contributor
•
19 Messages
11 months ago
It went back on its own around 7:30AM. I lost OFMDA upload channel. The upload drop from 119 to 80-90 Mbps because of this. However it is still better than 25 mbps before they upgrade upload speed to 100 Mbps on 800 download plan.
1
0
zandor60657
Contributor
•
200 Messages
11 months ago
I just got an email from Comcast saying my CM2050V has intermittent connectivity issues and the modem is defective but NetGear is working on a software update to fix it. That's not correct in my case since I had no issues with the v9 firmware, but at least it seems they're working on it.
I hadn't gotten the increased upload speeds yet, though before the firmware rollback I did have an OFDMA channel locked for a few months and the web site says 1200/200. A few months ago I woke up on two consecutive weekends to a modem that needed to be restarted. After the first one I noticed the OFDMA channel locked. Since then it's been stable and running at ~1400/40 (1200/35 plan) until today when I woke up to an outage in my area, which was fixed a little after 9am. No change in performance except for Comcast speed test being slow today, but that's elsewhere in Comcast's network and not on my line. Google and speedtest.net are still going ~1400/40.
My best guess at what's going on is the CM2050V v9 firmware has issues if it doesn't have a strong enough signal. My Xfinity internet connection has generally been very stable over the 6 years and change that I've lived here, and my signal stats are better than the vast majority of what I see posted on here. Of course that's to be expected since people usually only post signal stats if they have an issue.
Just in case you're curious:
Number Range
Codewords
Codewords
Codewords
2
0
SammyFL
Contributor
•
131 Messages
11 months ago
I also got the same email about my Netgear CM2050v modem. The v9 firmware did get on OFDM upstream channel, but my Gigabit plan still has 25mbps uploads. But I also had connection issues with V9. A few days ago it went back to firmware v2 and lost the OFDM upload (still have 25 upload speeds). But I did notice that my download speeds now start of slow and take about 20 seconds to reach the gigabit speeds (around 1150mbps). On the V9 firmware it got the full download speeds right away. Hopefully Netgear gets whatever the connection problem was fixed with V9.
0
AudioDave
New Poster
•
6 Messages
11 months ago
I can confirm that my modem received the firmware v2 recently. I also received the same email from Comcast about frequent disconnects and the firmware update, and of course, another opportunity to RENT a Comcast device. This after upgrading from the CM1150V that Comcast advised would not provide my full speed. Also had a modem failure that may be unrelated, but it causes some suspicion to determine that firmware updates have been pushed out. I did an RMA and have a replacement.
My speed have consistently been approx. 380Mb down/25Mb up.
Comcast repeatedly indicated during the summer that there would be periodic outages due to maintenance upgrades in my area. I've been living with the degraded service as I don't have much interest in multiple iterations of "going through the motions".
I am in the process of doing my internal maintenance and testing to assure myself everything is good. Once I reconfirm all my internal testing, hopefully we'll know more about the situation. Clearly there are issues with the modem, looking at the thread alone indicates consistent low performance and/or drops.
I've been communicating with some folks on the Netgear community forum about this issue and am working through the same old routine. Over the next few days, or slight delay due to holidays, I will once again go over my internal network and trying to gather data.
I am not pleased that I have upgraded the modem AND RMA'd a failed modem (which was possibly bricked for a failed firmware update that I cannot prove) only to end up with an expensive modem upgrade from the approved vendor list, and once again suggesting I RENT the Comcast solution, in addition to the already pricey monthly service.
I've been living with the 380/25 service, rather than continually go through this process!
That said, now that I KNOW there is an issue and confirmed updates of firmware and other having the same issues, it is even more frustrating to once again go through these hoops.
Again, I will work on my internal connections/configuration, modem reboots, etc. to satisfy myself I've done what I can do to isolate the problem(s).
There is clearly a common theme going on here!
(edited)
0
0