The Xfinity ID you entered was incorrect. Please try again.

I have another email that I've had for many years that I have forwarded to my main email. Now, when I go to log in to that email, it says it doesn't exist, yet I'm still receiving the forwarded emails on my main email. How can I log in to the email that is legit and still forwards to my main email? I have tons of accounts set up with that forwarded email.