Can you returned or exchanged used screen protectors?

yesterday (2/19/2023) I brought an Otterbox Alpha flex screen protector for my Samsung Galaxy S23 Ultra. Xfinity Moblie employee did me the favor of putting the protector on the phone. When I got home I noticed the screen protector was slightly crooked. I decided to remove it and applied it to the screen again to straighten it. unfortunately, the adhesive side got dirty and every time I try to put it on, it gets filled with bubbles that are hard to remove, and lines formed due to bending. Is there some way at least to get another screen protector as an exchange? I know Otterbox offers a lifetime warranty for their products but I'm not sure if they would replace one that was recently brought.