cwysong's profile

Visitor

 • 

4 Messages

Saturday, December 14th, 2024 11:37 PM

Comcast Email Autodeleting Messages

Disappearing email

I’ve noticed email disappearing from my account. It is quite often from my electric utility, my gas utility, the post office, and other notable businesses.

My configuration is Comcast email as the ISP and Windows Outlook as the desktop. I had this problem on Windows 10 and Outlook 2016. I now have Windows 11 and Outlook 2021.  The problem occurred on the old system and continues to happen on the new system.

How I can tell I’m missing mail, other than obvious things like monthly bills not showing up, is in the Windows Taskbar. The Outlook icon shows the new mail flag and the taskbar on the right shows the envelope signifying new mail.

I removed all rules from Outlook. The problem persisted.

I put rules in place in Outlook to ensure emails from domains I want (example: pse.com) are moved to the inbox. I also put the same rules in place on my Comcast email from the same domains to make sure I have everything covered. Some of the mail comes through, but some of it doesn’t.

What I found is that if I see the new mail icons and I look at the Outlook inbox, trash, and junk folders and don’t find anything, I go to the Comcast email account. Looking in trash doesn’t show anything. When I click on RECOVER DELETED ITEMS in Comcast email, I find the missing mail.

According to everything I have read about this issue, it can’t happen. But it does. I don’t think it’s my desktop software as I’ve moved versions and the problem still exists. I think there is something in the Comcast email system that starts to move it to my Outlook Inbox and decides something is wrong. It doesn’t move it to Spam. It doesn’t move it to Trash. It moves it to permanently deleted trash on the Comcast mail server.

Any thoughts on how to debug this further?

Thanks,

Chris

Official Employee

 • 

1.4K Messages

4 months ago

@cwysong I'm sorry to hear of your email issues.

 I would like for you to delete the setup you have and set it up again using these settings and ensure you select leave a copy on the server, so those emails are not deleted from your Xfinity inbox. 

How often do you have to recover emails or have missing emails? 

Visitor

 • 

4 Messages

I'm not sure I follow you. Delete what setup?  The rules? The email account?  Please help me and be more specific. How do I leave a copy of the email on the server?  I'm running iMap, so leaving the copy on the server would leave a copy in my Outlook session as well? Can I delete these from the server every day?  How long does this need to go on? I'm confused as to what you want me to do and what it will accomplish.

I have been seeing a disappearing message every 2 to 3 days. I knew I was missing messages, but I had no idea how many or how often until a few days ago when I found them in the Comcast permanently deleted messages.

Thanks,

Chris

Official Employee

 • 

1.6K Messages

That is a great question @cwysong. I believe that they were referring to the rules you have set up on the email address. 

I am an Official Xfinity Employee.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Xfinity: CARE, Product, Leadership.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit from the conversation.
Was your question answered? Please, mark a reply as the Accepted Answer.tick

Visitor

 • 

4 Messages

Thanks. On the Comcast email, I disabled the rules. On the Outlook email I deleted the rules after exporting them for later use.

How long do I run it without rules? Until I see a missing email?

What's next?

Chris

Visitor

 • 

4 Messages

It’s been a week since I removed the rules, and no further mystery deletions have occurred. I decided to look closely at the rules, and I have one that I think is causing it.

With all of the spam messages I’m getting (over 100 per day), I put together a rule that I had intended to be run only on the junk filter. I had it disabled, but I can only assume that I enabled it unintentionally.

When I set up this rule I had my security set to HIGH, and I was finding that valid email messages were being moved to the junk folder. This was causing me to look through all the junk email to find any messages that shouldn't be there. I thought that if I could build a rule to run against the junk folder I could delete all the real junk and leave the valid email behind. This should solve the problem.

The rule looks at URLs in the body of the junk email, and if it finds a match, it permanently deletes the junk mail. This rule is being run by a VB script, and once I had disabled it I assumed I was safe from it ever running against the inbox. I’m also assuming that one of the URLs I added to the rule was being used by a valid email message.

I only found a few valid messages, so I thought that by turning security to NO Automatic Filtering this would answer the problem. I found that almost all of the messages that were moved to junk were done so at the Comcast email level, not Outlook. Only a couple a day got past the Comcast junk filter.

And somehow I enabled the filter, and the mysterious deletions began a few weeks ago.

I’ll call this issue self-inflicted and close it for now. I appreciate everyone’s help in trying to solve this.

Official Employee

 • 

2.4K Messages

@cwysong Thank you for reaching out on the Community Forum for support with your email auto deleting issue. We are glad you were able to resolve your issue and provided some possible help to the forum. Never hesitate to create another public post for any of your future account and service needs!

I am an Official Xfinity Employee.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Xfinity: CARE, Product, Leadership.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit from the conversation.
Was your question answered? Please, mark a reply as the Accepted Answer.tick
forum icon

New to the Community?

Start Here