Regular Visitor
•
6 Messages
Formal Complaint - Deceptive Sales Practices, Misrepresentation, and Failure to Honor Promised Iphone 18 Promotion
Subject: Formal Complaint – Deceptive Sales Practices, Misrepresentation, and Failure to Honor Promised iPhone 18 Promotion
I am extremely disappointed, frustrated, and frankly outraged by the way Comcast/Xfinity has treated us as long-standing customers. What should have been a straightforward promotional upgrade has turned into an incredibly frustrating experience involving misleading information, a significant unexpected financial obligation, and an unwillingness by Xfinity to take responsibility for its store associate's actions.
In October, my son and I visited the Xfinity store to take advantage of the "Upgrade to the iPhone 18 On Us" promotion. We also understood that we qualified for free upgrades through our Premium Unlimited plan, which specifically includes eligibility for two free upgrades annually.
To be clear, my son was perfectly happy with his existing iPhone 17 Pro and had no intention of upgrading unless we qualified for a genuinely free upgrade. His existing phone was costing him absolutely nothing out of pocket because a monthly trade-in credit of $45.83 was being applied to our bill, covering the full cost of the device.
We specifically visited the store to verify our eligibility and ensure there would be no unexpected costs before proceeding. We sat with a store associate, Brian V., who explicitly reassured us that we qualified for the free upgrade and that trading in the iPhone 17 Pro for the new iPhone 18 would not cost us anything out of pocket. The only expense we were told we would incur was the applicable sales tax, which we paid in the store.
Brian further explained that once we returned the iPhone 17 Pro, the remaining 11 payments associated with that device would be removed from the line, and a new promotional credit and payment term for the iPhone 18 would begin on our next billing statement.
At no point did Brian explain that we would be responsible for paying off the remaining $504.20 balance on the iPhone 17 Pro before qualifying for the promotion. Had this been disclosed, we would not have proceeded with the transaction.
I was never presented with a contract to review. I do recall signing on the tablet Brian provided, but I believed I was authorizing the credit card charge for the sales tax we were paying in the store. I was told all transaction details and documentation would be emailed to us. However, I never received an email containing the updated contract or a clear explanation of the terms of this transaction.
Compounding the situation, the iPhone 18 was on backorder, which delayed both its delivery and our ability to return the iPhone 17 Pro. I was subsequently out of the country for 16 days and did not discover the billing issue until I returned. Had I received the promised contract and documentation, I would have had an opportunity to identify and address the discrepancy much sooner.
When I discovered what had happened, I attempted to find a reasonable resolution directly with the store. One option I proposed was to reverse the transaction entirely: return the iPhone 18 and reinstate our original iPhone 17 Pro. The store refused, claiming we were already outside the 14-day return window. This is an unreasonable response given that the phone was backordered, shipped to us, and the promised documentation was never provided.
I have now been to the store twice and have worked with both the store manager and assistant manager. While they acknowledged and apologized for the associate's mistake, neither was willing to offer a reasonable solution or take ownership of the situation. An apology without corrective action does absolutely nothing to resolve the financial burden their employee's misrepresentation has created.
I am now being told that the reason we did not receive the phone for free is that the remaining 11 payments on the iPhone 17 Pro, totaling $504.20, had to be paid off first. I am also being told that had we paid that amount in the store on the day of the transaction, we would have qualified for the free upgrade.
THIS IS NOT WHAT WE WERE TOLD BY THE STORE ASSOCIATE.
We relied on the information provided by Brian before agreeing to this transaction. Had he accurately explained the payoff requirement, we would have made an informed decision and either paid the balance at that time or simply kept the iPhone 17 Pro.
Instead, we are now being presented with a bill of $1,227.77 for a new phone that we were explicitly told would be free, aside from applicable sales tax. This is completely unacceptable.
I consider the circumstances surrounding this transaction to be a serious misrepresentation of the promotional terms and, at the very least, a deceptive sales practice. Xfinity's promotional marketing language also raises concerns about transparency and whether customers are being given a clear and complete understanding of the eligibility requirements and financial obligations before committing to an upgrade.
What is particularly disturbing is that Xfinity has acknowledged the store associate made a mistake but is unwilling to correct the consequences of that mistake. Customers should not be expected to absorb substantial unexpected costs because an employee provided inaccurate information, failed to disclose material terms, and did not ensure the customer received the promised transaction documentation.
I am requesting that Comcast/Xfinity take ownership of this situation and provide a meaningful resolution. Specifically, I expect one of the following:
-
Honor the original representation made by the store associate and adjust the transaction so that the iPhone 18 upgrade is provided at no additional device cost, consistent with what we were promised.
-
Alternatively, reverse the transaction entirely, allowing us to return the iPhone 18 and reinstate the original iPhone 17 Pro under its previous financial arrangement without penalty.
I am not asking for special treatment. I am asking Xfinity to honor what its representative explicitly promised and to make this right.
We have been long-standing customers, and the way this situation has been handled has significantly damaged my confidence in Comcast/Xfinity. The repeated apologies, lack of accountability, and unwillingness to offer a reasonable solution are unacceptable.
I expect this complaint to be escalated beyond the local store level to someone with the authority to review the transaction, investigate the associate's representations, and authorize an appropriate resolution.
I would appreciate a written response addressing the specific concerns outlined above and confirming what action Comcast/Xfinity intends to take to resolve this matter.




No Responses!