I'm currently investigating XH for my new home. Reading these posts, if your home router supports a DMZ, you should be able to put the XH security router in the DMZ and everything should work just as if it were directly connected to the Internet. Has anyone tried that?
Sir. I was unable to view from an external network as well untill I used the free services of Axis to enable NAT.
Once NAT was enabled, away went the issues. I have Axis Communications Ip cam. Unsure of your brand.
I hope this can lead you to help or to ask more questions.
Does anyone know where/who provides the services for the home security and HVAC setup?
I would like to work for them for a couple of years and become my Areas leader in IP cam and HVAC/Lighting control setups for xfinity...
Hi. What's stopping you from using an audio output into your home theater or maybe just some amplified speaker unit to increase your tone alarm?
Just a thought for a quick solve. If you are happy with the setup otherwise...
I can confirm this is true they set up the home security router in front of my personal router which I have a slingbox hooked up to I had to go into the advanced settings and it has the option under connectivity to allow personal router to be exposed to internet it finds your mac and you hit ok and it allows it through took all of 5 minutes to do and everything is working as it should with my slingbox. Definitely not for the basic user but I am a technician so I was able to figure it out,
The audio output on the device seems to have been disabled and within reason if the external audio device loses power then you would not hear your notifications and in the event of an emergency that could be a problem
As a side note I am using a linksys/Cisco E3000 router running a custom tomato firmware. Essentially if the MAC address is not found when you try the connectivity settings on the home security controller allowing your router to be exposed to the internet then something in your personal router settings will need to be changed.
Anyones help would be appreciated on placing private router in Comcast's DMZ..
For two months now, I've had Comcast's standard configuration working (Internet-Netgear-Private-routers.) Private cameras were exposed to to internet after configuration setting on panel (Advanced-Comm-Expose Private Router).
Now they've had to replace the panel and it can't find my private router to put into DMZ.
I had the Home Security installed on Saturday. They put a Netgear 150 N WNR1000v2 router on my Arris TM722G Telephony modem which I had hooked up to a D-Link 300N Dir-645 Whole Home router.They connected the Netgear to the modem and then hooked up my router to the #1 port on the Netgear (making my router an access point).
I tested my speed with Speedtest.net before they came out. I was getting 24.69Mbps download and 6.77Mbps upload. I tested it this afternoon, pinging the same server and my speed was 9.49Mbps download and 9.29 upload. It has totally bottle necked my speed and I'm payin for Boost!
The technician left me his number to call if I had problems. I have called repeatedly but Richard Devine evidently doesn't answer his phone.
I have one day to get this POS out of my house before I am locked in for 3 years and NOBODY will help. The rest of the Home Security setup is good, but using these 'end of life' routers is beyond stupid. I have an extra D-Link dir-655 and offered it to them to put in place of the 150N and they said it was what they were forced to use by Comcast. (The installers are contracted).
If any Comcast personnel monitor these forums, please help. I'm going to end up paying 3 years on something that I am going to disconnect. I have my own 8 security cameras that I monitor, and now I can't monitor them except inside my own home. None of my apps, nor logging into my network are available. This is FUBAR.
P.S. I too am a techie and I also put my router into their router's DMZ - no effect on speed.
The router that we use really serves just as a pass through. I have never seen any speed issues because of it. I have it at home and consistently get 50 and above with Blast.
Only suggestion I can give you without being there and troubleshooting myself is to reboot all 3 devices in order. Modem-security router-personal router. Also test speeds hardwired if you aren't already.
We aren't all contracted, I am an in house guy. "Forced" to use those routers is a weird way to put it- that's just how it was designed.
Being a new Comcast secuirty user also, my speeds are not afftected, advise to powercycle should be done to verify...
Now to my dilema with port fowarding - I used to be able to use my APP Plex but since the home security router has been placed in front of my router i cannot use this APP on my iphone outside of my network anymore.
I have 1 camera on my new security setup - What is the official Comcast work around for this issue?
Thanks in advance
Hi, i seem to have the same issue as everyone. comcast installed home security gave me their ip of 10.0.0.1 and hooked up my router to their router. no matter what i change on my router i can not longer do port forwarding. of course i cannot get into their router to fix. If i have my router first like old times the port forwading works but now the comcast ip changes every hour or so. this is a hassle since my son and his friends are using our server for a game and then i have to reset and they have to login again. any ideas on how to fix this! tried calling them and sorry their techs are idiots and even was goign to try their paid service but the lady hung up on me said she could not hear me. argh!
I have some contacts with the Home Security team, if you still have a problem PM me.
I have this same problem, please can you help me? My wifi has slowed to a crawl with frequent outages.
The installation of their router is not necessary.
You simply need to open port 80 on your existing router to ensure they can communicate with the alarm brain. Since most folks ( including the install techs ) do not know what the my first sentence means, they simply install their own hardware that is preconfigured for it.
At least this is how mine is configured.
When it was first installed, they couldn't connect to the brain. I fired up NMAP and ran a scan and noted that port 80 was wide open. Figuring that was the port they wanted to use, I simply opened up the port on the router and voila. Done.
Outside of celluar connection issues, no other problems with the setup since.
Any chance you could post details on how to do this for a tech dummy? Many thanks.
I was just installed yesterday and have had no speed issues. 50/11 to my laptop over my wifi router which is "behind" the Netgear security router.
One idea, I would make sure the security router and your personal router are not laid on top of each other, as the two wifi's might interfere with each other. Even a foot of distance between them might help.
The router that XFINITY installs is a second rate piece of $#@!. Ever since I have put it in between my router an ASUS dual band and the internet router, I get disconnections, lag issues frequently. At this point I have to determine if my monitors are more important or my hobby (gaming). I am very disappointed in the service! I wish I would have built my own. I would not suggest this service to anyone that actually uses their internet for things other than monitoring the place they put the security equipment.
I didn't read the fine print (early term fees only a very wealther person can pay) when I signed up, so I am stuck with this garbage for a couple more years.
All you people not having issues are probably because your not on as frequently as others. I am on my computer non-stop in the afternoons and weekends. It is not a constant issue, it is intermittent, but when it happens it is very annoying to people like me that use the internet constantly. Don't discredit other peoples complaints because you don't seem to have an issue, it's obvious others do and it is very legitamate.
Not sure if anyone still follows this post.
But I just got XH service today.
I was concerned when the tech installer said he had to install a router in front of my own router.
I asked him the reasoning for this was.
He told me that it was to prioritize the calls that the security system makes.
(Much like how other security systems tap into the phone line, ahead of your phone outlet, so that if your security system goes off, it will cut off your calls and dial to emergency services)
I didn't really want to squabble with the tech installer, since he seemed like a nice guy.
But I really think that this way of setup is really "Stone age" I would put.
We're on broadband, their calls don't take "priority"; they don't cut off our internet service in order to call out for emergencies.
The bandwidth is shared, even when they are calling out.
I did some research into their Netgear router and it seems it either runs a hidden SSID or N band SSID that consists of letters and numbers. It then communicates with the touchpad directly with comcast services and updates everything via your xfinity online panel.
One thing is good, that it does eliminate hardware troubleshooting for the company for majority of the people, but what it doesn't take into consideration is that we do use our networks for more than 1 task.
Putting their crappy preset router ahead of ours eliminates what a small percentage of us (Namely people who do networking) use our routers for, and for some, it bottle necks our network. And I guess we are the ones that complain.
For those of you who use the video monitoring system, I cannot speak for.
But I decided to throw the security system to the back of the bus. (How many times are they going to actually call in?)
I put it on the last point of entry on my network; the repeater.
Runs perfectly, did a communications check. Broadband and cellular service are both working as it should. My Xfinity home panel updating as it should.
I hope this helps some of you, because my logic here, is that my gaming, video downloading, and surfing should technically not "clog" up my system. As long as they're connected somehow, they'll be able to dail out. And yes, some of you are concerned that if your router goes down, so does the broadband for the security system. And hence why they have a cellular backup.
Linksys E3000 Flashed to TomatoUSB (Shibby)
Linksys WRT54GS Flashed DD-WRT Repeater
This issue has been fixed, at least in California. The XH router can now be set behind a personal router and work.
I was having camera issues, tech came out and put the XH router behind my Linxsys router. He explained Comcast has installed a new server for XH on the backend that allows this configuration without any hassel. Whole thing was fixed in 5 minutes of him arriving.
Following up. I am still not a fan of the el-cheapo netgear router. However, a tech came out and worked on my set up. It appears to be working much better now. He told me that your personal router can only be put in front if you have one of their new modems. The signal strength on the router is weak too, I am having issues with one of my cameras that is about 30ft from the camera... they are coming out Saturday to take a look, they said to install a repeater or move the modem. I prefer a repeater.
That's some bull**** and they know it.
I'm running my own modem and it works fine.
Even had a tech nearby run a connection test on my system and it says everything is being monitored as it should be.
Find yourself a cheap repeater, or a flash an old router thats capable of taking 3rd party firmware, and create a repeater.
Plug in their Netgear router where you see fit for optimal operation.
I have been struggling with the same crappy XH security router too. Can you give some more details as to what the tech did and how is your setup now? ...ie, internet>personal router (WAN/LAN ports)>XH security router (WAN/LAN ports).
Thanks in advance!
Hmmm, well i can tell you that as soon as my 2 years are up, i will get rid of the comcast security. First off having their router first blocks all of our port forwarding. And I have noticed since having their router installed that our bandwidth is funky. I can no longer stream movies to my tv without massive buffering. Anyone who uses their compuer for more that basic internet and email, i would not suggest getting comcast.
That is a bummer that you're experiencing bufferring. Fortunately, mine's been fine. I still get about 50 Mbps download over my N-wifi. We stream Netflix from two laptops, a Tivo and our TV and that's all still working fine. The settings on the Netgear are automated as far as I know so maybe a bad port or ethernet cable?
Well i have tried to do that and they ALWAYS want to transfer me to their "Pay for Service" division. So i have given up. I have less that 1 1/2 yrs left, i can wait it out!
Just had the XFINITY Home system installed. I was lucky to have a very knowledgeable engineer to perform the installation.
1. He checked cable levels and replaced ALL cabling outside the house and called another engineer to tune the transmitter in the street.
2. He added an amplifier and a 5-way splitter in the basement, just after the entry in the house.
3. After installing the Security Wifi in my office upstairs, we found out that the Netgear equipment could not communicate with the Touch Screen Controller downstairs. (There is a reason why I have an Apple Airport Extreme, which allows me to connect by Wifi in the whole house and even in the yard!)
As an alternative, the engineer installed a 2-way splitter in the family room. One goes to the X1R Cable Box and TV, the other to the XFINITY Cable Modem, with a connection to the Netgear Wifi, with its encryption security. The XFINITY Cable Modem also supports the phone system.
4. Upstairs, there is another 2-way splitter, with one path to the X1 and TV, and the other to a cable modem (UBEE). I attached my Vonage and Airport to the modem, without problems.
So far, I am keeping my fingers crossed, but everything is OK. The beauty of this setup is that we keep the Comcast stuff completely separate from my internet. I am with all of you, don't mess with my router.
Here is the layout:
Cable from the street ---- Amplifier --- 5-way splitter (two used)
Cable 1 ---- 2-way splitter --- X1R --- TV
--- XFINITY Cable Modem --- NetGear Wifi router .... Security Wifi
--- Phone system
Cable 2 ---- 2-way splitter --- X1 --- TV
--- UBEE Cable Modem --- Vonage --- Airport
I have had pathetic service with this system. Have to use the comcast provided modem which craps out and have had replaced with no effect. Service essentially has rendered my internet not usable from time to time. Had great internet previously with my store purchased motorolla modem.
Everytime I call for support they want to transfer you to their BS support hotline in India for paid support. I'll probably just bite the bullet and cancel the whole dame thing. Only time I ever got a reponse out of anyone was when I began cancelation process.
I would say go elsewhere and avoid like the plauge.
My home is protected with Comcast Home Security. On Tuesday afternoon on August 20th at 6:11pm
Does anybody here have any experience with Comcast Home Security's setup?
I have a home security system that I've never armed or had monitored. I was thinking of signing up for service and the Comcast Xfinity Home Security system with it's touchscreen keypad looked pretty good. So I call Xfinity Home and have to wait on hold for several minutes (and this is to sign up). Then they tell me they don't do consults but they can setup an installation appointment. So I do that and they give me a five hour appointment window 12-5PM. Not only that but you have to answer the phone two hours ahead of time or they simply cancel your appointment. How awesome is that? I love taking an entire day off work. So a guy shows up 2 minutes before 5PM and had nothing with him. Nothing. No equipment to install, no manuals to show me, nothing.
Ok, I realize that rant is beside the point. So talking to him he tells me that they install some unnamed piece of equipment between my modem (which may have to be replaced since he informs me it is end of life) and my router. He further says that he doesn't like working with Apple routers since they have to be set in bridge mode to be able to work with said unnamed piece of equipment.
So I start having alarms go off. First, nobody but me touches my router settings. Second, what is this piece of equipment? I think it must be some other router. Do they put that router in bridge mode? Doesn't sound like it which means mine would be the bridge. But why do they need a second router? Why can't I add the equipment to my network and simply open ports or a DMZ to equipment?
Does anybody have any experience with Xfinity Home Security's setup? I'd like to figure it out so I can see if it will work for me (after all, it seems an actual Xfinity person with knowledge of their products seems to nonexistent). Right now, I'm thinking I'll have to scrap Xfinity. It's a shame because their products look ok and the installation is a good price.
I have the Xfinitycomcast Home Security system and on Tues early evening at 6:11pm on August 20th 2013, My home was broken into The one intruder entered through the window and continued to my back door to open for the other 3 accomplices to enter the home and burglarlize and steel.
4 teenager Juveniles entered through the window with the comcast home securtity protection sticker in the window. Talk about brass balls.
The alarm sounded but did not stop them. From 6:11pm to 6:17 pm is when the call was placed to the police department. The alarms poor sounding decibels that sound cannot not be heard on the outside. What am I paying monthly for when they got in and stole my laptops and when through my rooms. The neighbors never heard the alarm. Hmmm. My neighbors who have ADT have a loud sounding alarm the neighborhood neighbors can hear. Comcast can not be heard outside the home. I do not feel safe with their system.
The Alarm was set for away statis when I left at 1:15 pm and armed the system in away.
The living room sensor activated, also the untility room and then the back door sensor. This should of been enough to notify the police immediately. not wait to text and call me and my father who is 2nd on the list.
My recommendation to you is talk to the response team of the montioring station and find out the length of time when the alarm is activated for them to notifiy the authorities. Also, find out how loud the alarm sounds if there is a breach of security. Comcast wants alot of money for a system that looks and sounds good but cannot not be heard outside.
I hope this helps. Good luck on choosing your security system
So is placing the home security router behind my personal router now supported or not? I'm in central jersey, have a little less than a year left on my contract, and will absolutely not be renewing if this isn't resolved.
I was told it would be supported "soon" when i signed up for the thing.
You are not understanding. I own my networking router. I understand that they provide a seporate dedicated router.
I do not want thier suporate dedicate router to sit between my modem, and my network router.
They were supposed to resolve whatever issues made this impossible.