Xfinity plant
Community Forum
Xfinity globe

Playback errors and constant restarting

Xfinity Forum Archive
About the archive project

Xfinity Forum Archive...

This is an archived section of the community.

Content in this area has been identified as outdated or irrelevant.

This change was done in an effort to make the forum easier to use and to keep only the most helpful and recent content active.

Post your questions in the Xfinity Community

Contributor

Playback errors and constant restarting

Today while watching recording on iPad it suddenly started buffering, restarting and then playback errors. Then when away from home told me in home only for iPhone playback. Working perfectly until yesterday. Deleted app, restarted modem, hard reset on devices, no change. Has there been an update or change to streaming? My download speed looks fine.

Accepted Solutions
Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Yes, believe it was a cloud issue which is now fixed.  Don't know if "syncing" on dvr menu had anything to do with it since was already working after 3 days.  Tech came to my home and did some cable replacements which he said could be causing the spikes seen on my router effecting playback but everything was already working fine and still is.  Hope the problem is fixed now. I received an email today asking me to accept solution that was in the very beginning about watching recorded shows away from home before they were done recording, which had nothing to do with the problem so I will not accept that as solution.  Wish they would respond to cloud fragmentsmissing when recorded as being the problem.! 


All Replies
Official Employee

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Hi spc823. Was the recording in progress? In progress recordings are only available to stream in home. Once it is recorded, you can watch it anywhere (within the USA). If it is a downloaded recording though, you are only able to view the recording on one device at a time and it has to be checked back in when you're done with it-- kind of like a library. 

 

Ken

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

I have the same issue. Programs were recorded the day before. Will not stream correctly on my roku, my iPhone, or my kindle. Even downloading the program does not correct the issue. This just started on Sunday. Did they do an update that is not working?

Official Employee

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

KCallahan, are you getting a specific error message or code when attempting to stream? 

 

 

Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Hi there

 

When playback doesn't work on all platforms, it's definitely not a client update that's the issue. Guessing something is wrong with the recording. The two of you appear to be in different areas of the country, but let me see if there's something that could have affected both of you. What channel was the program recorded on?

 

LHC




Community Icon
I am a Retired Official Comcast Employee, and I no longer actively support the forum.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Comcast: Product, Support, Leadership.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit from the conversation.

Was your question answered? Mark it as a Best Answer!solution Icon
Community Icon
I am an Retired Official Comcast Employee.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Comcast.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit.
Was your question answered? Mark it as a Best Answer!solution Icon
Community Icon
Retired Comcast Employee.
Please post so people with similar questions may benefit.
Was your question answered?
Mark a Best Answer!solution Icon

Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Not still recording. Was fine before modem was reset by billing agent that gave me a credit for billing blast as a separate item even though included in my double play. After that happened on Monday any recorded show constantly restarts tries to resume but stops again after several seconds and does it again. I called yesterday and today and was supposed to be contacted by tier 2 tech but never was called back.
Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

I record cbs morning show and MSNBC morning show and watch later in the day. I was able to watch on iPad with ios9 and iPhone with ios10 with no problems in home and away on wifi.
New Poster

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

I'm having the same issues. It just started about 7-10 days ago. I'll start watching a 100% completed recording (on my phone at home) and about 1-2 minutes in it looks to rebuffer and start again from the beginning. Or it will rebuffer and start again but it jumps ahead 10 seconds, plays for 20 seconds more then skips back to the previous place it rebuffed. This is happening on EVERY recording, but only from the app. Playing from website on my computer and playing on the TV are ok. It's only the app and it just started doing it recently.
Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Today, 8-10-17 the playback is working.  Tier 2 tech never called me back but I think something was done to the app.  I am watching on ipad and tested iphone.  Fingers crossewd the problem is fixed on their end. 

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

No codes. The recording jumps around and eventually displays the "it appears you are done want to delete?" message when it is only half way thru the recording.
Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

I can assure you that nothing was done to the app to break your recordings. What's happening is that some of the video files (called "fragments") are missing, which is wreaking havoc with the player. This appears to be happening with specific recordings. 

 

LHC




Community Icon
I am a Retired Official Comcast Employee, and I no longer actively support the forum.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Comcast: Product, Support, Leadership.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit from the conversation.

Was your question answered? Mark it as a Best Answer!solution Icon
Community Icon
I am an Retired Official Comcast Employee.
Official Employees are from multiple teams within Comcast.
We ask that you post publicly so people with similar questions may benefit.
Was your question answered? Mark it as a Best Answer!solution Icon
Community Icon
Retired Comcast Employee.
Please post so people with similar questions may benefit.
Was your question answered?
Mark a Best Answer!solution Icon

Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

so today the same morning shows that I record every day did not have "fragments" but they did on  Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday? Sounds like a DVR issue  or a cloud issue when playing back if not an app issue.  Whatever it is/was it seems to be fixed now.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Still happening here. Recordings are fine (no skipping) on the DVR. I've recorded programs on ID Channel, CBS, NBC, ESPN and USA to test the issue on different devices. All devices (iPhone, iPad, Kindle, Roku, & the Desktop) have the same issue. I've looged off and back on for each device. I removed the app from each of the iPhone, iPad, Kindle, and Roku and reinstalled. Same issue. The only thing I haven't done is reset the DVR. I'll do that later today after my wife's soaps finish recording.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Reset DVR, no change.  Although these were all recorded before the rest. I'll see what happens to the programs I record this evening tomorrow.

Expert

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

Reset DVR, no change.  Although these were all recorded before the rest. I'll see what happens to the programs I record this evening tomorrow.


if you reset (rebooted) your home DVR trying to fix a cloud DVR issue please note they are independent of each other (and don't even know each other exists). the Xfinity scheduler in the cloud does all the work on creating recordings in both.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Interesting and nice to know. Then please explain to me why, in the past, when I had to reboot the DVR during a recording I lost 3 - 4 minutes of that recording.  And, it was at the exact time the DVR locked up to when the DVR was back on line.  IF the cloud DVR controls everything, I would not have lost those few minutes.

Expert

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

Interesting and nice to know. Then please explain to me why, in the past, when I had to reboot the DVR during a recording I lost 3 - 4 minutes of that recording.  And, it was at the exact time the DVR locked up to when the DVR was back on line.  IF the cloud DVR controls everything, I would not have lost those few minutes.


you physically kept the local DVR from recording during that time. The cloud recording (check your cloud copy) won't have that gap as it is not using your home's cable service at all. You can literally unplug your home equipment and put it in the closet and watch your recordings on the cloud DVR using a smart device or Roku or web browser. Two completely separate recording devices and their own source of content.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

I can't verify that right now since my "cloud" recording seem to be corrupted. I will check it out sometime though.

 

Based on what you are telling my it's the cloud recording that is corrupted for the issue in this thread. IF that's the case, Comcast has an issue with their cloud drives.  Agree? 

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Update to my issue. I recorded three programs after restarting the DVR.  All three worked fine today. I watched one on the Roku, one on my Kindle, and the other on my iPhone. I can't say restarting the DVR is the solution, but, mine is working right now. We'll see how it works over the next few days.

 

I would like to know "how" the recording comes to the devices. Does it come from the DVR or from the router? I understand if you're not in your home it comes via the internet. But, in your home, I assume it's coming from the router, since you don't need the DVR plugged in to watch your programs.

Expert

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

Update to my issue. I recorded three programs after restarting the DVR.  All three worked fine today. I watched one on the Roku, one on my Kindle, and the other on my iPhone. I can't say restarting the DVR is the solution, but, mine is working right now. We'll see how it works over the next few days.

 

I would like to know "how" the recording comes to the devices. Does it come from the DVR or from the router? I understand if you're not in your home it comes via the internet. But, in your home, I assume it's coming from the router, since you don't need the DVR plugged in to watch your programs.


all 3 of the devices you listed are only able to view assets on the "cloud" DVR. The home DVR can be unplugged for the recording time and the cloud DVR records and offers playback of its files. The cloud DVR does not use your home equipment at all.

Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

an update to my problem.  Tier 3 tech called back tonight at 9PM (after 2 days)  and said the issue looks like  spikes in signal on my router and cable box on  Monday-Wed. .  She is scheduling a repair visit  to look at those even though working ok now.  She also said to go to settings  on cable box from remote (press xfinity button, scroll right to settings to devices) and sync dvr recordings.  She said sometimes that can lead to problems with the cloud recordings. She also renamed my 2.4 and 5.0 wifi(which had same name) so that I can choose which one my devices  connect to saying that the ones closest to the router should be 5.0 and farthest away 2.4.  The  problem was after she did that we lost all our connections to all our wirless devices, phones, lap top, ipads,printer,  thermostat, tv, apple tv and garage door app..  We are now reconnecting  to either the 2.4 or 5.0 connection.  What a pain!

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

IOW, the recorded data comes from the router. So, the issue could be with the router. I do know they are doing "maintence" on the system the last few days and the router is reset. I know this because I have a wifi camera that shows it was disconnected each of the past three nights. 

 

All this still brings more questions. Where does the home dvr get its recording? I assume the cloud dvr. If so, why does a recording work OK on the home dvr, but skips on the other devices if it's the same data? There has to be something that causes this issue. And, that's what I'm trying to determine so if the problem comes back, I know to reset that device whether it's the router or the home dvr. Based on your input, it would have to be the router or something external to my home.

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


KCallahan wrote:

IOW, the recorded data comes from the router. So, the issue could be with the router. I do know they are doing "maintence" on the system the last few days and the router is reset. I know this because I have a wifi camera that shows it was disconnected each of the past three nights. 

 

All this still brings more questions. Where does the home dvr get its recording? I assume the cloud dvr. If so, why does a recording work OK on the home dvr, but skips on the other devices if it's the same data? There has to be something that causes this issue. And, that's what I'm trying to determine so if the problem comes back, I know to reset that device whether it's the router or the home dvr. Based on your input, it would have to be the router or something external to my home.


When a recording happens, it is recorded to your STB DVR and your cloud DVR. Your STB DVR contains the recording it makes and the cloud DVR contains the recordings it makes. Therefore there are two copies of your recording. When you watch a recording from the STB DVR, the data is taken from the STB DVR and sent to be displayed on your tv. If you are watch a recording from the cloud DVR, the data is taken from the cloud DVR and sent to be displayed on your device. The STB DVR can hold more data than the cloud DVR.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Thank you for that information. So really, the only device using the STB DVR recording is the tv connected to the home dvr. All the other devices (iPad, Kindle, etc) use the cloud dvr recording. Knowing there are two copies of the same recording clears up a lot of my confusion with this issue. Of course, it doesn't fix the issue. 

 

 

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Wait, I think I misunderstood the term STB (set top box). I have the x1 dvr and there is no hard drive. It was my understanding all the recordings are in the cloud. Therefore, only one recording for the home dvr and to be used for the other devices. If I download a recording to my kindle, I can't watch it on my home dvr. 

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


KCallahan wrote:

Wait, I think I misunderstood the term STB (set top box). I have the x1 dvr and there is no hard drive. It was my understanding all the recordings are in the cloud. Therefore, only one recording for the home dvr and to be used for the other devices. If I download a recording to my kindle, I can't watch it on my home dvr. 


Which X1 box do you have? I'm not aware of any X1 DVRs that don't have an internal hard drive, if they didn't have one, how can they be a DVR? Prior to comcast implementing cloud dvr, the recordings were just saved to the STB DVR. Once they released cloud dvr, when a customer had cloud dvr added to there account, only new recordings since adding cloud dvr were on the cloud dvr. Any recordings made prior to adding cloud dvr to their account were only on the STB DVR. When you download a recording, you can't watch it on your home DVR due to their rules, not part of this discussion.

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


KCallahan wrote:

Thank you for that information. So really, the only device using the STB DVR recording is the tv connected to the home dvr. All the other devices (iPad, Kindle, etc) use the cloud dvr recording. Knowing there are two copies of the same recording clears up a lot of my confusion with this issue. Of course, it doesn't fix the issue. 

 

 


True, when you look at your list of recordings on the app or web site, you are looking at the recordings contained on your cloud dvr. When you look at list of recordings on on your STB DVR you looking at the recording contained on your STB DVR. Since they are different sizes and one may not be able to record when scheduled, the list may not be the same.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Technically it's called x1 cloud dvr. And, there is no internal hard drive. 

 

I have the AR AX013ANM dvr, if that makes any sense. And, my issue is part of the discussion. My dvr playback with no issues. It's the roku, kindle, iPad apps that have issues.

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


KCallahan wrote:

Technically it's called x1 cloud dvr. And, there is no internal hard drive. 


Then your telling me you don't have an X1 STB DVR . . . Do you have the XFINITY Stream package? If so, you have a X1 cloud DVR TV box which is not a DVR. Your only DVR would be the cloud DVR.

 

More info here:

https://www.xfinity.com/support/cable-tv/x1-dvr-with-cloud-technology-available-features/

 

And here:

https://www.xfinity.com/support/cable-tv/x1-dvr-with-cloud-technology-activation/?currentTopicId=c71...

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


KCallahan wrote:

Technically it's called x1 cloud dvr. And, there is no internal hard drive. 

 

I have the AR AX013ANM dvr, if that makes any sense. And, my issue is part of the discussion. My dvr playback with no issues. It's the roku, kindle, iPad apps that have issues.


According to this page:

 

https://www.xfinity.com/support/cable-tv/set-top-box-energy-usage/

 

The Arris AX013ANM is a DVR, therefore it does have an internal hard drive. Your dvr plays recordings with no issues because it is holds the recordings. This technology has been around for a long time. Your other devices have to get the recording from the cloud dvr which is new to comcast and really isn't ready for prime time.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

That's what I said in my last post.  But, the cloud DVR works just fine. It's the apps that have the issue. So, IF there's only one recording, in the cloud, why do I have issues with the apps and not the cloud dvr? 

 

Of course, the problem is not there at this time. I reset the cloud dvr yesterday and the programs I recorded after that work just fine on the apps. I don't disagree resetting the cloud dvr shouldn't fix the problem. So, it may be just coincidental.  I'm just trying to narrow down the possble cause so if the proplem reoccurs in the future, I can fix it at my end. 

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

PS - Yes, I have the Xfinity Stream package.  And, we love it. we travel alot and can watch our recording on the road. Saves on binge watching when we get home.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

That being said, I was lied to when I was upgrading my system. Not that it has made a difference until now. But, it does point to the issue being with the cloud dvr. Which, I have no control over.

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

That's what I said in my last post.  But, the cloud DVR works just fine. It's the apps that have the issue. So, IF there's only one recording, in the cloud, why do I have issues with the apps and not the cloud dvr? 

 

Of course, the problem is not there at this time. I reset the cloud dvr yesterday and the programs I recorded after that work just fine on the apps. I don't disagree resetting the cloud dvr shouldn't fix the problem. So, it may be just coincidental.  I'm just trying to narrow down the possble cause so if the proplem reoccurs in the future, I can fix it at my end. 


Not sure about your cable box, everything I find says the Arris AX013ANM has a hard drive. This web page even includes pics of the insides showing the hard drive.

 

http://www.dslreports.com/forum/r30335360-X1-X2-New-XG1-A-lacks-hard-drive

 

If comcast disabled or removed the hard drive from your box since you only have the stream package and not the x1 dvr with cloud dvr package, then the only reason I can come up with why when you watch recordings on the STB are fine but not on mobile devices is that the STB gets the data over the cable while the moblie devices get there data over internet communication.

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

That's what I said in my last post.  But, the cloud DVR works just fine. It's the apps that have the issue. So, IF there's only one recording, in the cloud, why do I have issues with the apps and not the cloud dvr? 

 

Of course, the problem is not there at this time. I reset the cloud dvr yesterday and the programs I recorded after that work just fine on the apps. I don't disagree resetting the cloud dvr shouldn't fix the problem. So, it may be just coincidental.  I'm just trying to narrow down the possble cause so if the proplem reoccurs in the future, I can fix it at my end. 


Also, this comcast help page for the xfinity stream package indicates that you would not have a STB.

 

https://www.xfinity.com/support/cable-tv/stream-faqs/?currentTopicId=c0da3465-ce96-4a4e-a3d9-60f6005...

 

Are you sure you don't have X1 DVR service with cloud dvr?

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

When I look at my account it shows Xfinity on x1 TV. In the writeup it indicates "with streaming video thru cloud technology". Nothing in my account shows "X1 DVR service with cloud dvr". 

 

 

So, you tell me what I have. I only know the model of the box that I have, which I gave you. I also have an x2 box in the master bedroom. I can view recordings on my Roku, iPad, iPhone, Kindle, and desktop PC. They all use an Xfinity Streaming App.

 

 

Bronze Problem Solver

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting


kcallahan47 wrote:

When I look at my account it shows Xfinity on x1 TV. In the writeup it indicates "with streaming video thru cloud technology". Nothing in my account shows "X1 DVR service with cloud dvr". 

 

 

So, you tell me what I have. I only know the model of the box that I have, which I gave you. I also have an x2 box in the master bedroom. I can view recordings on my Roku, iPad, iPhone, Kindle, and desktop PC. They all use an Xfinity Streaming App.

 

 


Sorry, I can't tell you what you have. You can call comcast and ask them. Everyone that has the X1 package with cloud dvr can stream with the Xfinity Streaming App. If you have multiple STB and one of them is the Arrris, my guess is you have X1 service with cloud DVR, not the xfinity streaming package.

Frequent Visitor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

What I have doesn't make any difference to the issue. Right now, all the streaming app recordings are working. Like the original poster, I had playback errors on all the streaming apps. When playing through the TV, the recordings and no errors.

 

Everyhthing I've read in this thread leads me to believe it was the cloud dvr with the corrupted recordings.  I just wish Comcast would acknowldge that. When you call they want to reset the dvr and/or reset the modem. Of course, until you do a recording and check it later, you don't know if it has been fixed. And the original ticket has been closed so that when you call be, they go through the same steps.  It's just ftrustrating. 

Contributor

Re: Playback errors and constant restarting

Yes, believe it was a cloud issue which is now fixed.  Don't know if "syncing" on dvr menu had anything to do with it since was already working after 3 days.  Tech came to my home and did some cable replacements which he said could be causing the spikes seen on my router effecting playback but everything was already working fine and still is.  Hope the problem is fixed now. I received an email today asking me to accept solution that was in the very beginning about watching recorded shows away from home before they were done recording, which had nothing to do with the problem so I will not accept that as solution.  Wish they would respond to cloud fragmentsmissing when recorded as being the problem.!